I am not a grinch. I am a scientist. I excite with all things learning and science-filled. Give me a vomiting cat, and I love running tests and asking questions to figure out what is going on with the poor creature. I adore working with top level veterinarians to work through the problem and come out on the other side successful. This includes both Eastern and Western medicine. However, I have found in my 13 years of practice that naturopathic medicine in animals is a lot of hooey, and it bilks the owners out of a lot of money. It also pisses off the veterinary specialist you are paying to save the life of your pet. I have an example of the type of people who bring in supplements of a naturopathic nature for their pet....
 |
awwww random internet kitteh is cute |
I had a client once, relatively recently, who was.....a character. A difficult one. Ms Character came to our clinic an hour later than she made the appointment for. We had been warned of this, and although Dr Internist didn't want to see her, we squeezed her in. Ms Character, of course, did not approve, and spent 15 minutes of my time complaining that she had to wait. While I was attempting to get a history on the cat. We shall call this particular cat Precious because she was very sweet.
Ms Character insisted that her primary care vet was inept. This was my second sign that she would be a difficult client. Any client that complains about her primary care vet (PCV) will most certainly complain about her specialist. A specialist has higher cost, and thereby more responsibility due to the schooling and training and talent the specialist has to offer. Ms Character insisted her primary care vet overlooked kidney disease in Precious. However, there were many notes in the PCV's record about how the owner refused to treat the kidney disease, and instead relied on her naturopathic friend to give her 'medicine.'

This woman dumped out a bag of 'medicine' in front of me and described in detail how she committed terrible acts of administration to poor little calico Precious. There was a kidney scrubber and a liver cleanser and an appetite stimulant....all of them in powder form that the owner would sprinkle over Precious' food till she stopped eating....then the powder went into a syringe with water and was squirted into the darling's mouth. Ms Character was livid that the PCV didn't understand why Precious wasn't eating, and was now anemic with kidney failure and dying.
As a vet tech, there are three things I am NOT allowed to do.....diagnose, prognose, and perform acts of veterinary medicine without a supervising licensed veterinarian. Looking at this cat, who was bright and alert and responsive, had beautiful mucous membranes that provided a quick capillary refill time, and appeared well hydrated, I would have never known she had abnormal lab values. However, her lab values weren't very bad at all. She was barely azotemic, and had honestly never been anywhere near acute kidney disease bad enough to warrant Ms Character thinking her Precious would die. Ms Character had been offered hospitalization and diuresis for her kitty, but had declined it in favor of the supplements. Despite all claims, Precious looked healthy and acted healthy and ate treats for me in the room.
Dr Internist was going to be annoyed. This client was only here because the owner insisted. the primary vet could have easily have handled this, and this client is difficult, obstinate, and loony toons. Dr Internist doesn't DO naturopathic medicine, because we, as a veterinary community, do not know how the ingredients affect the patient pharmacokinetically. Just because something seems to work in humans doesn't mean it is right for animals (chocolate, raisins, and xylitol are big examples of what is good for humans and bad for dogs, and Tylenol is lethal in cats). and Dr Internist has her own way of doing things.
It took an hour, but Dr Internist convinced ms Character to back off on the supplements. Ms Character refused to let Precious stay the night, and so we gave her some fluids under the skin, a few injections, and let her go. little did we know, she would be back two days later....
 |
if only cats could talk.... |
Precious isn't eating now. i mean, she wasn't before, but now it's been two more days. the owner phoned for an urgent care visit and got the last slot of the day. she was, again, and hour late. i got the pleasure of letting her know the emergency vet would be seeing her. She blew up in my face. And, it turns out, she never stopped giving the supplements. And there was no way Precious was getting into the other cat's food. Even though the owner had to drag her away from the other cats' food dish to bring her to the clinic.....
huh?
yeah.
Turns out the supplements didn't taste good, so Precious was eating the other cat's food. Which wasn't a specific kidney diet, so it didn't help Precious pull herself away from the brink of kidney failure. All of this is so simple, but Ms Character focused on other things. Like how we are never ready for her when she arrives. And how the Dr Internist refused to see her when she showed up after closing time, despite having an appointment an hour prior. And how dare we say she was an hour late when she was, in fact, on time and the receptionists didn't allow her to go into the room for an hour (untrue - I had been in the lobby looking for her because she had told me over the phone that Precious was on the verge of death...).
 |
it's like random internet kitteh grow'd up |
Ms Character left in a huff, refusing to pay a cent, despite having agreed to blood work while she waited for the Dr Emergency Vet. And the hospital manager, being a complete tool, let her go without payment.
The moral of this story, I suppose, is that naturopathic medicine has it's place in the placebo category of medicine. There are some natural agents that we use, like milk thistle for liver problems, and Yunnan baiao for clotting problems, but that is because they are proven to be of use by the FDA. There is a stringent vetting process for medications for a reason.
Personally, I have seen wonderful responses with chiropractic and acupuncture for pets. This is because stimulating nerves and adjusting bones to not compress nerves are scientifically proven to work. Acupuncture works through 'channels' that happen to lie right over nerves. Funny how that works out.